Search New York Death Records
- New York Newspapers, Full Search (1730-2018), 1,027 titles
- New York Obituary Search - (1870-current)
- New York Birth Records Database, (1767-1999)
Old Methodist Cemetery
Middle Island, Suffolk County, New York
Old Methodist Cemetery, Middle Island, NY
GPS: 40.87717, -72.96864
Middle Country Rd (NY 25) & Brian Court
Middle Island, NY, 11953
Published: February 11, 2020
Total records: 18
Located on the southeast corner of Middle Country Rd (NY 25) & Brian Court, adjacent to Barnwood Market.
Old Methodist Cemetery had been the primary burying ground for the original Methodist Church. In 1858, it's congregation dismantled the church building and relocated it about 2 miles west in the town center of Coram. Today, it still stands there as "Trinity United Methodist Church". When the church was moved, the congregation began using a new burying ground, "Trinity Methodist Cemetery".
A sign erected at the site of this Old Methodist Cemetery reads...
"Please respect and enjoy, Burial Ground No. 44, Old Methodist Cemetery, Middle Island, At the Heart of Brookhaven, Drive Carefully, Don't Litter, Smile!"
The document linked below contains a reading of tombstones by Elbert N. Carter on 21 June 1964 ...
Search New York Cemeteries
Submit a Transcription
Help genealogists worldwide research their family history!- No cost to publish your transcription
- You retain all rights to your work
- No one can edit, change, or delete your work